Cornwall Pizza: The Quest for the Perfect Pie

August 12, 2025

In the city of Cornwall, Ontario, a culinary secret has been simmering for decades, drawing fans from hundreds of kilometers away and sparking an unexpected, yet passionate, provincial rivalry. We’re talking about pizza – but not just any pizza. Cornwall’s unique, thick-crusted, cheese-laden pies have become a pilgrimage for food lovers, with many going to extraordinary lengths to get their fix.

What makes Cornwall pizza so special? Locals and visitors alike point to several distinguishing features. Unlike the thin, crispy crusts popular elsewhere, Cornwall’s pizza boasts a substantial, doughy base that can stand up to its generous toppings. And speaking of toppings, these pizzas are famously loaded, piled high with fresh ingredients. But perhaps the most iconic characteristic is the cheese – a thick, golden blanket that often extends right to the edge, covering all the delicious toppings, creating a satisfyingly chewy, flavorful crust. This distinctive style is upheld by several unique, family-run pizzerias, each contributing to the city’s rich pizza tapestry while maintaining the beloved “Cornwall style.”

The devotion to Cornwall pizza is so profound that it’s not uncommon for people to drive hours from “up north” or even as far as Toronto, specifically to buy multiple pies. The ultimate testament to its allure? Many customers purchase extra pizzas to freeze, ensuring they can enjoy a taste of Cornwall long after their visit. This practice of “pizza-to-go” has become a local legend, a testament to the irresistible quality of the city’s signature dish.

Adding to the fun, the Cornwall Visitor Centre has even started selling “Cornwall Pizza Rulers” – so you can see for yourself just how thick these legendary pizzas are! You can also grab official Cornwall Pizza T-shirts to show your love for the city’s iconic dish.

Stacey Case, affectionately known as the “Cornwall Pizza Guru,” encapsulates this fervent passion. “There’s just something about Cornwall pizza that gets under your skin,” Case enthuses. “It’s the perfect combination of history, family tradition, and that incredible, thick, cheesy goodness. It’s more than food; it’s an experience, a connection to home for many.”

The deep-seated love for Cornwall’s pizza, championed by enthusiasts like Mr. Case, has recently escalated into a friendly yet fierce challenge. The question on everyone’s lips: Who truly has the best pizza in Ontario – Cornwall or Windsor, another city with a strong pizza identity? This burgeoning rivalry has ignited debates across social media and local eateries, daring connoisseurs to put their taste buds to the test.

Do you want to take the pizza challenge? Come to Cornwall, sample its legendary pizza, and decide for yourself. For more information and to discover the unique pizzerias that make Cornwall a pizza paradise, check out Cornwall Pizza.

We’re here to help!

Got questions? Looking for recommendations? Cornwall Tourism is here to help! Give us a call at 613-938-4748 and we will be happy to assist with any questions you might have.

#ExploreCornwallON

Looking for other fun things to do in Cornwall? Check out the Explore section of our website for other fun-filled activities to keep you busy. Better yet, consider extending your stay with a night at one of our great accommodations!